|“||Don't you dare walk away from me. I swear to god, Tyler, if you take one more step we are done, ok? No more surprises, no more excuses, no more chances. We are done.||”|
Originally, the two do not like each other. She thinks he's hot-headed and tempermental, and he thinks she's spoilt and selfish. After Caroline breaks up a fight between Tyler and Matt and Tyler kills Sarah, she's the first to realise that he has activated his curse. Tyler, suspicious of her, soon discovers that she's a vampire. She tells him that she's the only vampire in town, as to protect Stefan and Damon. She comforts him throughout his transition.
After discovering that Caroline could have died by being so close to him, Tyler's touched and kisses her. Shocked, she slams the door in his face and later explains about her existing feelings for Matt. When Jules arrives, she informs Tyler that Caroline lied about being the only vampire and that she knows what happened to Mason. Tyler confronts Caroline, believing she betrayed him. After Tyler hesitates in saving her from Jules, Caroline turns her back on him, and he leaves town with Jules without saying goodbye.
Greta and Maddox kidnap both Tyler and Caroline upon his return to town. Caroline informs Tyler that they have been lined up to be executed in Klaus's sacrifice, however, Damon arrives to save Caroline. She convinces him to save Tyler too, and ends up running from Tyler with Matt after he turns. Later, Caroline informs Tyler that Matt broke up with her and he comforts her.
Tyler and Caroline form a strong friendship. Caroline's jealous when Tyler brings Sofie to Elena's party. She compels Sofie to leave, leading to Tyler confronting her. They end up sleeping together. However, when Caroline tries to sneak out, Carol kidnaps her and delivers her to Bill to be tortured. Tyler and Elizabeth save her and she begins a relationship with Tyler. However, upon Klaus's return, he turns Tyler into his first successful hybrid. As a result, Tyler becomes sired to Klaus and begins to rely on Rebekah for blood. Tyler leaves town to break the sire bond and, when he returns having been successful, is unhappy to learn that Klaus has fallen in love with Caroline. After Klaus's "death," Caroline tearfully kisses Tyler goodbye, unaware that Klaus is in fact in Tyler's body.
Tyler is later returned to his own body. When Klaus bites Caroline, Tyler carries Caroline's body to where Klaus is, saying that he deserves to watch her die. After Klaus heals Caroline, he threatens to kill Tyler but she convinces him not to. Instead, he gives Tyler a "head start" and tells him to start running. Thus, Caroline and Tyler bid a tearful farewell and break up, promising it wouldn't be forever. Before Klaus leaves town, he tells Caroline he has a graduation present for her and gives Tyler the freedom to return.
Tyler defers from college much to Caroline's sadness. He returns to comfort her about Bonnie's death. They have a brief reunion, but Tyler reveals that he plans to kill Klaus, thus leaving town again. She warns him that it will be over between them if he leaves, but he does so anyway.
They are referred to as' "Tyroline" or "Forwood" but less commonly, "Cyler" or "Tyline" by fans.
The Vampire DiariesEdit
Tyler and Caroline were initially mutual friends and would hang out sometimes and play pool. This was probably because they'd known each other since infancy. When Matt avoided Tyler due to his incident with his mother, Caroline tried to make amends between them. Caroline joked with Tyler about getting drunk enough until someone is hot enough to make out with. In Season 3 Caroline tells Tyler she didn't like the old him.
Season Two When Caroline became a vampire and Tyler a werewolf, they found themselves understanding each others' situations and they ended up building an unexpected friendship. They started to spend a lot a time with one another, confessing their thoughts of being a supernatural being and bringing them closer.
In Masquerade when Matt starts punching him and Tyler refuses to fight back, Caroline hears the commotion and arrives at the fight quickly. She pulls them apart, punching Matt on the nose that he falls on the ground, unconscious. Sarah stands up, muttering: "Matt failed. If Matt fails, I can't." She picks up a knife and Caroline yells to Tyler to watch out. He pushes Sarah backwards and she hits her head against a desk.
As she lies motionless on the floor, Tyler begs her to open her eyes and repeats: "This can't happen." Caroline tests Sarah's pulse and realizes she is dead. She asks Tyler what is happening and he looks at her with werewolf's eyes. Later, the duo tell Tyler's mother that Sarah was drunk and just tripped over. When she leaves, Caroline tells Tyler that Matt is sleeping it off in the car and promises to deal with him. Tyler asks what she is doing and Caroline explains that she is fixing a "very bad situation", adding that Tyler didn't mean to kill Sarah. "But she's dead," he says. "You don't know what that means." Caroline insists that she does, and when Tyler replies that she doesn't, she asks if his wound has healed. He checks, asking how she knew.
In Rose, Tyler is walking through the school corridors. He notices a memorial for Sarah and looks at it until someone knocks into him. He goes to open his locker, but breaks the lock due his new strength. Later, he approaches Caroline and asks how she knew about him. "That you were upset?" Caroline replies. "I thought I was doing a good thing by covering for you." Tyler tells her that he's not talking about that. Caroline pretends not to understand and leaves.
Afterwards, Tyler is playing basketball but spots Caroline. He approaches her and asks why she lied to him earlier. "I think you misunderstood me at the party," Caroline replies. "I get it, it's very traumatic." Tyler insists that she's lying, and when she tries to leave he grabs her. However, Caroline uses her strength to push him away. Tyler asks how she did it but Caroline pretends she doesn't know what he's talking about. "If you know something you've got to tell me because I can't handle this," Tyler pleads. Caroline claims that he is just in shock. Tyler leaves and kicks over a bin in anger, but it flies away and hits a car. When Caroline arrives home, Tyler sneaks up behind her and tells her: "I know you're just like me, aren't you?" He says that he won't leave until she tells him the truth. "You're a werewolf, say it!" he yells. Caroline laughs, but Tyler pushes her up against a wall frustrated, telling her to stop lying. "I'm not lying," she replies, before pushing him back. Her teeth come out, revealing that she is a vampire, and says: "I'm not a werewolf, OK?"
Later, Caroline hands Tyler some alcohol and explains that it helps her to relax. Tyler admits that he feels as if his skin is on fire and says that everything has been heightened emotionally. Tyler is shocked that Caroline is a vampire and asks who else is like her, but she lies that she is the only one. Tyler explains that he is the only werewolf he knows apart from Mason. Caroline announces that Tyler cannot tell anyone about them. "This is life and death," she says. Tyler admits that he has no one else to tell. "I'm sorry about earlier," he says. "It's just I'm alone with this. It's going to happen to me. The next full moon I'm going to turn and I won't be able to stop it. I'm scared." Caroline hugs him to comfort him.
In The Sacrifice, back at school, Tyler is playing basketball by himself. Matt approaches him and apologizes for picking a fight with him. He admits that he has been avoiding Tyler because he doesn't know what to say. Tyler accepts his apology and Matt leaves, running into Caroline. They chat for a moment but Matt claims that he has to get to class and walks off, leaving Caroline unhappy with the state of their relationship. She heads over to see Tyler and asks if he has figured out what he's going to do at the full moon yet. He reveals that he has a plan but says that it is private. However, Caroline persuades him to let her help out.
Tyler and Caroline walk through the woods and Tyler admits that Matt is struggling to get over Caroline. Caroline agrees but insists that it is better this way. Tyler claims that he understands, saying: "You can't be honest with him. It's not really fair to be with someone and not let them know who you are. I get it." He points out the Lockwood cellar and explains that he thinks Mason was headed there on the night that he turned. The pair go downstairs and Tyler points out the old claw marks on the walls and the bolts and chains. Caroline discovers something wrapped up and, when she opens it, finds a journal. The pair realize that Mason kept a diary of what happened to him. Tyler reads: "The full moon is tonight." Caroline asks if Mason wrote down what happened, and Tyler finds a memory stick in the back of the book.
At Caroline's house, Tyler puts Mason's memory stick into a computer and the pair discover that Mason taped his first transformation. Caroline looks at the journal and finds that he wrote about it the next day. As they watch Mason being sick on the tape, Caroline reads that he tried to drink wolfsbane to make him weaker. "Over an hour passed and nothing happened," she reads. "It got so quiet I could feel my own blood pumping... I kept thinking I'd black out and not feel it but I did. I felt all of it." The pair watch Mason writhing in pain and skip through the tape, realizing that the process lasts at least five hours. Tyler begins to cry, saying: "I can't do that Caroline. Whatever that was, I can't go through that."
Meanwhile, Caroline suggests that they shouldn't read anymore of Mason's journal. "There's a reason it's called a curse, Tyler," she adds. Tyler takes the book and sees that Mason described the transformation as "unimaginable pain" and "the worst night of [his] life". Caroline reassures him that the transformation speeds up and suggests that he just needs to get through the first time. Tyler asks why she is helping him because they have never been close before. Caroline admits that she had no-one to help her when she turned. "I had no control over my body or my urges and I killed somebody," she admits. "I don't want that for you." The doorbell rings and Caroline gets up to answer it. She discovers Matt, who explains that he was driving home from work and found himself there. "I miss you," he admits. Caroline smiles, but Tyler appears, causing Matt to look confused.
In By the Light of the Moon, Meanwhile, Caroline and Tyler drive to the woods and Caroline reassures Tyler that Mason probably just stopped to surf somewhere. "I'm sure he's OK," she adds. Tyler begins setting up chains in the Lockwood cellar and Caroline reveals that she brought some wolfsbane with her. Tyler reaches over to touch it but it burns him. He explains that he brought some water with him and asks Caroline to mix the wolfsbane into it. Tyler continues to set up the chains and reveals that the set-up should be able to hold 5000 pounds. However, he admits that he doesn't know if a werewolf can pull more than that. He takes off his top and Caroline is shocked, checking that he is not going to get naked. Tyler asks: "What should I wear?"
Later, at the Lockwood cellar Caroline reveals that it is almost 8 o'clock. Tyler explains that the transformation could happen before the moon hits its apex. He admits that he doesn't know how long he will actually be a wolf, but suggests that it will be for a few hours. He grabs the bottle of wolfsbane water and Caroline asks if he is sure he wants to drink it, but Tyler insists that he does because it will diminish his strength. He drinks and immediately starts coughing. Caroline rushes over to soothe him but he shouts at her to leave. She refuses and, as Tyler apologizes, strokes his head.
Tyler is still struggling with his transformation and gasps as some of the changes begin to take effect. "I'm burning up," he groans. Caroline advises him to breathe through this and again he tells her to leave. "Not yet," she replies. Tyler begins screaming and pulling against his chains and Caroline gets up and begins crying, covering her mouth with her hand in shock. "It hurts," Tyler groans.
Back at the cellar, Caroline admits that she doesn't know how to help and Tyler tells her that there is nothing she can do. Suddenly, his back begins to bulge as the transformation continues. Tyler begs her to get out as he doesn't want to hurt her but Caroline refuses and takes his head. She hugs him and advises Tyler to fight through it. Tyler continues to tell her to go, but she whispers: "I'm right here. I'm not going anywhere." However, Tyler begins to convulse and groan. His eyes turn yellow and he snaps at Caroline. Caroline gets up and runs over to lock the metal gate to the cellar. "I'm sorry," she cries. Tyler bares his fangs at her and Caroline runs out of the cellar. She shuts the wooden door at the entrance to the cellar and sobs as she hears Tyler screaming and groaning. Eventually, he becomes silent, but then he bashes against the door. Caroline pushes up against it as Tyler barges up and tries to knock it down. "Tyler, don't," Caroline pleads. "Stop." She uses a plank to hold the door in place before running away through the woods.
Later, Caroline is walking through the woods. She arrives at the cellar and looks down the steps. She heads downstairs and examines the door, which has some damage but is still shut. She calls: "Tyler" and hears him mumble "Caroline" in return. She bursts in and spots him curled up on the floor. She covers him up to keep him warm and says: "You're OK, you're OK. You made it. You didn't get out. You're OK." However, Tyler sobs and replies: "No I'm not."
In The Descent, Caroline is at school preparing for a barbeque when she spots Tyler. She congratulates him on surviving his first full moon without hurting anyone. Tyler thanks her for being there and the pair stare at each other for a while. Caroline breaks the silence by suggesting that they should reinforce the cellar wall because he almost pushed it down bit her. Eventually, she reveals that legend says werewolf bites are fatal to vampires. However, the duo are interrupted by Matt, who asks to speak to Caroline, and Tyler leaves.
When Caroline gets home, she discovers Tyler waiting for her. He asks her why she would risk death to be with him, and Caroline replies that he needed help. Tyler points out that he could have killed her and says he doesn't understand. Caroline asks why it is so hard for him to let people help him. She begins to get angry, sarcastically saying that she's sorry if she overstepped her boundaries by caring about him. Tyler interrupts her speech by kissing her, but Caroline eventually pulls away after kissing back for a while, telling him that he can't do that. "Everyone just needs to stop kissing me," she yells.
In Daddy Issues, Jules reveals to Tyler that Stefan and Damon are also vampires and that his uncle Mason is dead, most likely killed by one of the vampires in Mystic Falls. Tyler confronts Caroline, asking her if it's true and she hesitates, prompting Tyler to believe Jules and shove Caroline against her car door, yelling that he trusted her. His eyes flash gold in his anger and he leaves a shocked Caroline behind. Stefan then confronts Tyler, telling him why Caroline lied to him and that they don't need to be enemies but friends. Caroline, after a short meeting with Matt, runs into Jules and tries to intimidate her, but Jules sprays a can of vervain in her face, causing Caroline to recoil. Caroline is then shot in the head with a wooden bullet by Brady, a werewolf friend of Jules'.
Caroline wakes up and finds herself in a cage, where Brady tortures her, spraying vervain in her face and shooting her with wooden bullets. Jules calls Stefan and tells him to bring Tyler to her in order for Caroline to live. Stefan takes Tyler to Jules but Damon soon joins the meeting, saying that if they did not give Caroline to him, his version of things would be more 'bloodier'. Jules whistles and a bunch of men appear from the woods, carrying fire gas tanks and wooden stakes. Damon tells Tyler to go to Jules, then attacks her, which leads into an all out battle between Damon, Stefan and the werewolves.
Tyler finds Caroline inside a caravan and Caroline asks him to open the cage for her, because there is no latch and she can't reach it. He hesitates and Caroline looks at him in surprise and anger, begging him to open the door. Tyler eventually does, letting Caroline out, who runs outside to join the fight but is immediately overthrown by Jules. As Caroline stares at Tyler to help her, he does nothing, watching her guiltily. As Damon is about to be staked, Dr. Jonas Martin enters the clearing, using his powers to knock the werewolves unconscious. He tells Stefan and Damon that Elijah would keep his promise to Elena to keep them safe, and that they should leave. He then warns Tyler to tell his 'werewolf friends' to leave town immediately.
Tyler goes to Caroline's house after the ordeal, realizing the error of his mistakes. Caroline is furious with him, angry that he did not help her when she was in trouble, stating "you just stood there!" Tyler tells her he didn't know they would come after her and that he doesn't know who to trust, because she lied to him. Caroline tells him that she lied to him to protect her friends and to protect him and Tyler apologizes but Caroline tells him it's too late, and that they aren't friends anymore. She slams the door in Tyler's face and he leaves, going back to Jules and her werewolf friends, where he tells them that Mason was looking for a moonstone before he died.
Stefan, worried about Caroline and how she is dealing with what she went through, goes to Elena and Bonnie for help, who decide to have a slumber party at Caroline's house. As they walk through the front door, Caroline begins crying, hugging them both closely as they embrace her.
In Crying Wolf, Tyler bumps into Caroline at the Grill, which causes her bag to fall and it's contents to spill out. Tyler steals her phone, but genuinely tries to talk to her, but she refuses, still furious at him for hesitating to help her during the confrontation with the other werewolves in the previous episode. As Caroline leaves, Matt tells Tyler to stop lying to him about Caroline and to just stop pretending that they aren't together, even though Tyler tells him they truly aren't together.
Tyler texts Elena with Caroline's phone, asking where she is so that the other werewolves can kidnap her, as they want to break the sun and moon curse and need Elena, as she is the Petrova Doppelgänger. As Stefan and Elena attempt to go on a romantic getaway at her parents old cabin, Tyler and Brady, another werewolf, attack Stefan in the garage and Brady goes inside the cabin to get Elena. Stefan tells Tyler that there is an alternative to all of this, but Tyler tells him he doesn't want to be a werewolf anymore, and that the only way that can happen is if he breaks the curse, as he can stop himself from changing if it is broken. Stefan tells Tyler that if they want to break the curse, Elena will have to die and Tyler realizes that Jules and the others have lied to him. He helps Stefan stop Brady from hurting Elena. Stefan kills Brady and Tyler apologizes to Elena, telling her he was unaware that the curse involved sacrificing her life. She forgives him and they hug.
As Carol Lockwood, Tyler's mom is heading up the stairs, she hears a noise and finds a letter from Tyler with 'Mom' written on it. Tyler approaches Matt at the Grill and tells him that him and Caroline were only ever friends, and that she helped him with a lot, and because of that, he developed feelings for her. He tells Matt that although he loves Caroline, Matt is better for her, and that he shouldn't let her go. Tyler goes to Caroline's house but hesitates on ringing the doorbell, but Caroline sense somebody outside and goes to the door. She locks it, unaware that Tyler is watching her from outside. Tyler enters a car and we see Jules in the passenger seat, where he apologizes to Jules about Brady, and says that if he's going to travel with her, he wants nothing but the truth from her and she agrees, telling him he's doing the right thing. He says he can't stay in Mystic Falls, not as a werewolf and they leave Caroline's house.
Finally, Tyler returns in The Last Daybecause his mom is in the hospital after 'falling' down the stairs. At the hospital, Jules arrives and tells Tyler they have to leave and lock themselves up in preparation for the full moon. Outside, Tyler bumps into Caroline and they have an awkward conversation, in which Caroline asks him why he just left without saying goodbye to her. As he explains that he left for a reason. Tyler begins to leave but Maddox and Greta appear, forcing Tyler and Caroline to fall on the ground in pain. Greta injects Caroline with vervain and they drag the pair away.
Down in the tomb, Caroline realizes why they've been captured, and tells Tyler the story of Klaus, and admits that she thinks he is going to kill them. Tyler tells her that Jules has been helping him come to terms with being a werewolf but it wouldn't matter now. Caroline then asks why he didn't say goodbye, wondering "why did you leave me?" and Tyler admits that he thought she hated him and deserved better than having someone like him in her life. Caroline admits that she was hurt but could never hate him. Damon arrives and reveals that Matt is outside with wooden bullets. He frees Caroline, but she refuses to leave without Tyler. Tyler admits that he can lock himself up in the Lockwood cellar and Damon agrees to untie him.
Caroline, Damon, and Tyler exit the tomb and meet Matt, but the full moon is emerging and Tyler's transformation process begins. Tyler's transformation is moving on and he tells them to leave. Damon has to push Tyler down but Tyler tries to bite him. Damon says he is fine and tells Caroline and Matt to lock themselves in the Lockwood cellar. He rushes away. Meanwhile, Caroline and Matt rush down to the cellar but are confronted by a wolf.
In The Sun Also Rises, the episode opens with Matt and Caroline trying to fight off Tyler, who has transformed into a werewolf. Matt worries that the gate in the tomb won't hold and eventually shoots Tyler. Caroline grabs his hand and they rush off. They return home and Matt reveals that he knew Caroline was a vampire because he has been drinking vervain, adding that it was Sheriff Forbes's idea. Caroline asks how Matt is feeling but he changes the subject, pointing out that they are stuck in the house hiding from Tyler. Suddenly they notice someone at the door and discover Tyler curled up on the porch. Caroline covers him with Matt's jacket and eventually gets him inside. Matt admits that he has enjoyed the last few days with Caroline but adds that he doesn't think he can deal with her being a vampire. He reveals that he already has a tough life but he just wants to live it without dealing with the supernatural as well. When Tyler wakes up, he admits that he should not have returned to Mystic Falls. However, Caroline tells him not to leave again. She admits that Matt broke up with her and Tyler hugs her as she cries. After her suggestion that instead of bailing on her he could thank her for taking care of him and stay, he does.
In The Birthday, at the Mystic Grill Caroline also suggests to Tyler that Tyler's mum kept eyeing her up when she was over. Tyler helps Caroline and Elena set up for Elena's Birthday, Tyler mentions to Elena that she might've confused Damon to meaning Caroline told Tyler about Elena and Damon Kissing after Elena Leaves Caroline says to Tyler "Just because I tell you things doesn't mean your allowed to know them.". Tyler reveals that he's bringing a date to Elena's party - "Slutty Sophie", according to Caroline. Caroline's naturally a bit hurt by this but she pretends that she's cool. After admitting, they both are very "horny" because of their supernatural states Caroline breaks the tension by saying to Tyler "I hope you get lucky". Caroline is downing alcohol at an alarming rate as she watches Tyler dance with Sophie, she appears jealous and hurt. Matt appears, but it soon turns into an argument about Tyler and Caroline and Matt's Relationship and Tyler comes over to check everything's OK prompting Matt to leave after he does so Sophie compliments Caroline on the party, she Jealously compels Sophie to go home leaving Tyler confused as she walks away., Tyler and Caroline argue about Tyler dating to which Tyler asks why he shouldn't be dating.
Tyler says he won't date anyone else if Caroline just tells him not to because last time she 'shut him down'. Caroline at first tries to deny jealousy and then gives in and kisses Tyler passionately. Tyler suggests they leave. They hastily leave the party and have sex in Tyler's bedroom. The episode ends with Caroline sneaking out and being shot with a Vervain Dart by Tyler's Mother. after touching her Vervain-laced purse.
Tyler puts two and two together and realizes his mom spiked his morning cup of coffee with vervain. Meanwhile, Carol has contacted a mysterious man about Caroline, saying that the problem needs to be fixed. The man assures her he'll deal with Caroline. Later on, Tyler confronts his mother, asking her why she spiked his coffee with vervain. She explains that she's known about Caroline for awhile, and that she was afraid Caroline may have turned Tyler. They soon begin yelling at each other, with Tyler asking her what she has done to Caroline, and Carol telling him to stay away from her. She calls Caroline a monster, and Tyler stares at her angrily, then tells her to come with him to the slave quarters. He places his mom in corner and locks her in, then chains himself up as he begins transforming into a werewolf. Carol watches on in horror.
As Tyler's transformation ends, he wakes up and sees his mom watching him from her cage. She agrees to help save Caroline and he thanks her. Carol calls the mysterious man and tells him that she made a mistake. The man refuses to budge though, and says that Caroline is a vampire, and needs to be taken care of. Caroline is soon revealed to be in a dungeon of some sort, tied to a chair by chains. She calls out for help, but no one is there. The mysterious man is eventually seen coming down some stairs, and Caroline calls out to him. He opens the door and walks in, and Caroline looks at him. He says hello to her, and she whispers, "Daddy?" revealing that the mysterious man is Caroline's father.
In The Hybrid, Carol Lockwood is seen pouring vervain in a pot of coffee. Tyler is heard coming down the stairs, and he kisses his mom on the cheek and pours himself a cup of coffee. Carol watches him anxiously, and berates him over him sleeping with Caroline. Tyler drinks from the coffee, and notices something different about the taste, but does not react, which causes Carol to calm down as she realizes Tyler is not a vampire. He leaves, but not before telling his mom off for offending Caroline. Tyler is next seen at the Grill with Elena, helping her find a mountain in Tennessee where some werewolves may be located. He asks her if she has seen Caroline and Elena tells him she hasn't. Tyler is next seen shooting pool and texting Caroline. She does not reply. Matt comes up to him and tells him the full moon is approaching. Tyler asks him if he's seen Caroline and Matt tells him he hasn't. Matt offers to help Tyler with the full moon, as Caroline is not around, but Tyler declines his offer. He drinks the coffee Matt has poured for him and wonders what's wrong with his taste buds. Matt tells him it's the vervain, and that Sheriff Forbes has been making him put vervain in the coffee at the Grill to help keep the citizens of Mystic Falls safe from the vampires.
In The End of The Affair, Later on in the episode, we see Liz Forbes leaving a voice mail for Caroline about lunch plans. She has no idea of the state Caroline is in because she’s been at work. Just as Liz hangs up the phone, we see Tyler knocking on their front door.
Caroline’s dad locks Caroline up for the night and is greeted by Liz and her gun. Caroline overhears their conversation, including her mom coming to her defense. “Let me do this, Liz,” Caroline’s dad says, “not because she’s a monster, but because we love her.” Liz doesn’t comply and calls for Tyler instead. She shoots a threatening bullet at Bill when he tries to block the entrance to the torture chamber and gives Tyler the O.K. to rescue Caroline. Tyler breaks the locks on the door and the steel contraptions around Caroline’s arms and legs. She mentions her ring, so he grabs it and places it back on her finger. Finally, Tyler picks her up and carries her to safety.
Back at the Forbes residence, Caroline is finishing up a much needed blood bag. She’s sitting on her bed under the covers and her mom is sitting at her feet. She hands the blood bag to Liz, thanks her, and lies down. Tyler appears in the doorway to Caroline’s bedroom, so Caroline’s mom gets up and goes to leave. Before she does, Caroline says, “Hey mom? Thanks for believing in me.” After Liz is gone, Tyler jokes about giving Caroline a hard time for sneaking out on him. Caroline laughs but it turns into crying. She makes room for him and he climbs into bed next to her. “He hates me… My dad hates me…” Caroline says tearfully and Tyler does his best to comfort her as the scene fades out.
In Disturbing Behavior, Caroline hides out in Tyler's bedroom when she sees her father at the party downstairs. After football practice, Tyler returns home to find Caroline lying on his bed waiting for him. He is happy to see her there but instantly becomes concerned for her when she reveals that her dad is in the house. Tyler offers to kick Bill's ass causing Caroline to laugh and makes up and excuse to why he shouldn't. She reveals that even through everything that's happened Bill is still her dad. Tyler gets what she means and stokes her hair causing Caroline to rest her head on his chest. But she quickly pulls away and comments that he reeks. Tyler jokes and says that it’s sexy while Caroline laughs. Tyler then leans in to kiss her as she kisses him back. Caroline proceeds to remove his shirt as he lies on top of her and they continue to kiss and begin to make love. But they are interrupted when Elena calls and says that it's an emergency.
In The Reckoning, both Caroline and Tyler are participating in Senior Prank Night. Caroline is putting honey on the doorknobs and Tyler starts kissing her from behind. They get on the topic of Matt. Tyler tells Caroline “I love how big your heart is” and tells her that he is happy. They begin to make out until they are interrupted by Rebekah, who seems to want Tyler for something. Caroline steps in between Rebekah and Tyler, but Rebekah attacks Caroline and takes Tyler with her. When Caroline wakes up she finds Tyler lying beside her, dead. Rebekah tells her that he is in transition to be a hybrid and Caroline stays by his side anxiously waiting for him to wake up. When he does, she explains to him that he is in transition. Rebekah steps in and tells him that unless Bonnie is successful, he is dead. Caroline assures him that he will be fine. When Klaus brings Tyler Elena’s blood to drink, Caroline tells him not to drink it, but he has to otherwise he’ll die. He does and he changes into a hybrid. Caroline and Tyler walk down the hallway holding hands as Tyler explains that he feels great. He picks her up and swings her around and they kiss. He tells her that “this is going to be an amazing year” and then hugs her, although Caroline has a worried look on her face the whole time.
In Smells Like Teen Spirit Caroline catches Tyler "Wearing his breakfast to school" (blood). Tyler assures her it was a blood bag and when Caroline asks him where he got it he replies that Rebekah supplied it. Caroline asks why he's even talking to her but he reveals that Klaus asked her to protect his new "asset." Tyler acts amused and Caroline points it out. He seems to like being Klaus's first hybrid. Caroline cannot believe that he likes it. At cheerleading practice Rebekah shows up to fill an open spot on the team and tells Caroline that she may go after her boyfriend. Caroline is angered by this remark.
After noticing that Tyler compels his football coach to stop practice early, Caroline confronts him saying he needs to be more subtle. He remarks "Coming from the queen of subtlety" and assures everything is under control. He then tells her that being a hybrid is a gift from Klaus. Rebekah is then seen showing off her cheerleading moves. She smiles mockingly at Caroline and Tyler tells her "Damn new girl has moves" which angers Caroline even more. Damon later reveals, after staking him with a vervain needle, that Tyler has been sired to Klaus, Caroline asks how they can help but Damon says the only way to fix it was to find a new boyfriend. Caroline tells Tyler the truth when he wakes up but he denies it. She tells him that lately he's been acting like the pre-wolf Tyler, the guy she would never be friends with. She starts to leave but Tyler stops her telling her that he does not want to be his old self and that he hated that guy. He adds he likes being with her. After having sex, Caroline leaves and Rebekah shows up, convincing Tyler to drink human blood, which he gives in to.
In Homecoming Tyler is helping Caroline decorate the 60's van and Tyler suggests to go out for a bite. Caroline then offers her thermos filled with blood, but Tyler rejects it saying he wants to feed on an actual person. Rebekah has apparently revealed to Tyler that there are people who want to be fed on without being compelled.
Caroline tells him that he needs to stop hanging out with the evil blood slut. Tyler tells Caroline to be nice to Rebekah because Matt is taking her as his date to the dance. Caroline expresses her concern that it is not safe for Matt to be going with Rebekah because he's innocent. Tyler points out that Matt drinks vervain so she can not feed on him. Later the dance is cancelled due to mysterious flooding. Klaus? Tyler? or maybe another hybrid? Tyler then moves the dance to his house where Klaus set up everything.
After Klaus reveals that there are other hybrids at the party, Tyler stabs Caroline with a vervain needle in the neck. Tyler tells Matt to take her home because if anyone tries to hurt Klaus, he will attack and he wants Caroline to be safe. Caroline wakes up later pissed. Tyler tells her the only reason he did it was to protect her from Klaus. Caroline tells Tyler that he could have just told her to go home because she was in danger and watch Dancing with the Stars. He then tells her that if she knew her friends were going to attack Klaus would she have left? She agrees that she wouldn't have and Tyler says " See, I saved you from your stubbornness."Tyler tells her that if the price to being Klaus' lackey is so that he never has to be in pain because the full moon forced him to and he can transition into a werewolf when he wanted to, then it is worth it. Caroline tells him she can not be with him knowing he is one of the bad guys now. Tyler leaves angrily.In Our Town Caroline arrives at school to find Tyler waiting for her. He apologizes to her because he is sired to Klaus and that he won’t be able to put Caroline before anything else. He gives her a charm bracelet and tells her “Happy Birthday”. Tyler crashes Caroline’s “birthday-funeral” after receiving a text from Caroline. Tyler asks to talk to her. They go into the woods and he tells her to forget everything he said earlier. He tells her that Klaus can’t control him when it comes to her. He tells her he loves and then kisses her. He begins to kiss her neck, but then bites her neck because of his sire bond to Klaus, even though he didn’t mean to. He begins freaking out and she yells at him to leave her alone, so he goes away. Once Matt brings her home Klaus comes and heals her bite.
In Heart of Darkness, Tyler returns to Mystic Falls, having broken his sire bond to Klaus (after turning approx. 100 times). He and Caroline meet again in the woods after a long time apart- and end up having sex in the Lockwood Celler. Upon returning to Mystic Falls, Caroline informs Tyler that once an Original dies, it's entire bloodline dies along with it. Tyler is extremely distressed- after Caroline tells him that if Rose, Katherine, Damon, Stefan and her own bloodline was not originated from Klaus, then they were all going to kill him. However, Caroline informs him that she just got him back, and she is not loosing him again. He finds one of Klaus's arts on Caroline's table, he gets furious and leaves her place.
In Dangerous Liaisons . Seemingly confused, Tyler questions Caroline, asking her why she kept it. Jealous that something might have happened between Klaus and Caroline while he was gone, Tyler leaves Caroline's house.In Do Not Go Gentle, Caroline plays a big part in preparing the Decade Dance, along with Rebekah. Tyler shows up at the dance determined to make up Caroline's mind about him, and he and Caroline dance together until Klaus shows up. Although Tyler has broken his sire bond, he and Caroline do not want Klaus to know that. He voluntarily steps aside so to let Klaus dance with her. Klaus informs Caroline he is leaving, and tells her they both know she is not up for coming with him. He walks away without saying another word.
In the school gym, Stefan informs Caroline and Tyler that Esther is at the old cemetery and that Matt and Jeremy are headed there at that moment. Tyler confesses his anger in letting Caroline dance with Klaus, before Caroline tells him that she loves him.
In Before Sunset, Tyler and Caroline were to meet at school to help organize the messy after party but Tyler call to her for inform that he can not because Klaus does not allow it.He helps Damon and Stefan "temporarily" kill Klaus. Later Tyler and Caroline are celebrating with others the supposed death of Klaus.
In The Departed, Elizabeth and Carol tell Caroline and Tyler to leave the town, as Alaric told the council that they are supernatural creatures. Tyler promises Caroline that he will take care of her and later on, she rushes to the Lockwood cellar, crying because Klaus is assumed dead and Tyler will die as well, being sired to him. Unknown to her, Tyler has been possessed by Klaus because of Bonnie's spell.
Growing Pains, Caroline, who was supposed to be away from Mystic Falls but stuck around because she didn't know where to go without Tyler gets captured by Pastor Young and the deputies. Klaus, who was in Tyler's body rescues her, and she is overjoyed and surprised when she sees that "Tyler" is alive. Caroline and Tyler/Klaus are later shown making out in the woods, right before Caroline discovers that the person she thought was Tyler is actually Klaus and slaps him, as she was very close to having sex with him. Caroline and Tyler/Klaus turn to Bonnie and ask her to put Tyler back in his body, which she does.
In Memorial, Tyler is in his bed having sex with Caroline, who feels bad because they are having sex in spite of all the tragedies going on, Tyler says that if they stopped having sex every time somebody died in the town they'd explode. A few minutes later Connor comes to Tyler's house and shoots him as soon as he finds out that Tyler is a vampire, attempting to kill him. However,Tyler, not being a regular vampire survives and escapes. At the sight of all the blood on the floor, Caroline gets very scared for Tyler. A the council's funeral, Caroline tells Stefan that if the hunter hurt again Tyler she'll kick his ass. She does everything to keep Tyler safe.
In The Rager, Caroline goes to the Lockwood Mansion, and Tyler tries to prevent her from entering, as his werewolf friend Hayley is there, and Caroline doesn't know about Hayley. At first, Tyler tries to hide Hayley from Caroline, so Klaus assumes that Tyler and Hayley hooked up while he was away.In The Killer, Caroline is at the Lockwood Mansion, informing that her mother has squad cars blocking the street. She first meets Hayley there. She finds out that Hayley has been staying there for the past few days, and that she's Tyler's friend. Caroline gets instantly jealous, especially after she overhears a phone conversation between Klaus and Tyler in which Klaus tells about Tyler having cheated on her. When Hayley and Tyler comfort each other over the death of their hybrid friend Dean, Caroline wants to know the truth. Caroline confronts Tyler, who explains that Hayley and him never hooked up, but are trying to make Klaus thinking that they did to hide the fact that they're progressively unsiring all of his hybrids and Caroline understands.
In We All Go A Little Mad Sometimes, The two act like they have broken up in front of Klaus. Carolines agrees to go on a date with Klaus if he agrees to kill off one of his hybrid, in order to save Elena. When Tyler learns about this deal, he gets really angry and throws a glass at the wall.In My Brother's Keeper, Tyler and Caroline's relationship has gone back to normal, although is kept in secret. Caroline went to the Mystic Falls Pageant with Klaus, while Tyler went with Hayley. Tyler seems to have forgiven Caroline, for he only wants to get rid of Klaus now.
In We'll Always Have Bourbon Street, Tyler rescued Caroline from the unsired hybrids who were torturing her. One of the hybids, Kim, wanted to prove to tyler that she was the Alpha. After some bargining from Elena, Tyler rescued Caroline and asured himself as "The Alpha male".In O Come, All Ye Faithful, Tyler makes a plan to have his own body used to get rid of Klaus, much to Caroline's chagrin. Caroline suggests they use Rebekah's body instead, an idea Tyler loves, although Hayley doesn't let them do this. Tyler says, "You're a genius, I love you," to which Caroline replies, "I love you, even when I hate you."
In After School Special, Rebekah kidnaps Caroline and she calls for Tyler to go to her rescue. Tyler arrived, and Rebekah told them all to stay in the building and not vamp run in the hallway. She compelled Tyler to turn into a werewolf. Now that she had Shane, she didn't need them. They were just competition, and whoever finds the Cure first gets to decide how to use it. Later, she found Tyler in the gym, lying naked in the fetal position in front of his mother's makeshift memorial. She held him as he broke down and apologized. "This whole thing, this is all my fault," he said. "I should have saved her."
In Into the Wild, Caroline arrived in the Elena's house to ask Tyler to come home, but he insisted he’s going to spend every moment with Klaus until he can kill him. Klaus tried to say they were even—Tyler’s mother’s dead, his brother’s dead—so they should tell Bonnie to let him out. But Caroline, remembering Aunt Jenna was also among Klaus’ death toll, said she’d never help him and that he wasn't even worth the calories she burns talking to him. That’s when Klaus impaled her with the other end of a lamp, pulled her to him, and bit her.
Later, Klaus made Tyler beg for him to give Caroline his blood to save her, and then he refused to do it even if Tyler became his slave again in exchange. Then Caroline told Tyler to get her out of there because she couldn't even look at Klaus.
Eventually, Tyler came up with a plan: Knowing that Klaus does care about her, Tyler took her back to him so he’d have to watch her die if he didn't want to help her. She asked Klaus how he could do this to her and Tyler. He said it’s because he’s pure evil. After Klaus decided save to her.
In Down the Rabbit Hole, Caroline and Tyler came with sword of Klaus and discovered it has cryptex under its hilt. Caroline got Jeremy's tattoo pictures from Rebekah in order to solve the puzzle in the sword and she said Klaus can help if he wants. Klaus said that magic of Internet wont be enough to solve the cryptex. Caroline didn't understand meaning from Hunter's mark and the language written means. Later Klaus helped her by translating in Aramaic Language which neither Tyler or Caroline understood.
Caroline told Rebekah by speaker that she send the details and pictures of Cryptex to her e-mail. But Klaus said to Rebekah that he helped them and told the told the Translation of Cryptex in English that there is only one dosage of Cure. Tyler was worried for his life but Caroline asked him to let her talk to Klaus to fix it and she did not want to say goodbye again.Later, Caroline begged Klaus for Tyler's freedom and said for her to stop looking for Tyler. Klaus said her Tyler has to leave town out if his sight, far away from him.
Tyler shared a last moment with Caroline outdoor and Tyler said she has to forget everything about how they met in love and every romantic episodes in her life until they find a way. She cried and kissed for last time and said until they figure a way out of this and Tyler with no option left Mystic Falls.
In 'Stand By Me ,Caroline later left a voice mail to Tyler telling him something happened and to call her. Caroline told Tyler by voice mail that Jeremy died.
In Bring It On, Caroline continues to leave him voicemails, stating that she hopes that if she leaves enough of them, when Tyler comes back he'll be all caught up, then it will be like he never left. However, at the end of the episode, Matt asks Caroline to come over to Tyler's house, and reveals that he left the deed to his house in Matt's name, in order to provide a safe haven for her that Klaus can't reach. Reading the letter Tyler left for her, Caroline realizes that he is not actually going to come back, and she begins to break down into tears.
In Because the Night, Klaus interrupted Caroline’s clean-up duty, and after she told him she can hate him for driving Tyler away even if Tyler was plotting to kill him, Stefan revealed he’d asked Klaus over because they need his help to find Silas.
In American Gothic, when Caroline gets a bunch of calls from Klaus, she goes to his mansion and finds him suffering. he begs her to take the shard of white oak out of his back, She says she'll do it—if he promises to let Tyler come back to town. And, of course, doesn't kill him. Klaus does not like these terms one bit.In Pictures of You, At Tyler's place, Caroline was prepping for the after party when Tyler showed up. Tyler and Caroline danced their last dance, and he thought he could sneak out before anyone saw him. Klaus was on the porch waiting to ask if it was worth it to give Caroline the night of her dreams. In the shared interest of not ruining Caroline's evening, Klaus gave Tyler a five-second head start and Tyler disappeared.
In Graduation (Episode), as a Graduation gift to Caroline, Klaus gave Tyler his freedom back, allowing him to return to Mystic Falls. The two are expected and most likely will continue their relationship where they left off.
I Know What You Did Last Summer, Caroline is finishing packing up things she will take to Whitmore College, speaking on the phone with Tyler. She is also preparing everything for his arrival; since she assumes he will soon join to her, Bonnie and Elena at college. But later, Caroline receives a voice mail from Tyler which tells her that he can't return with her because he is still helping a pack of wolves in Tennessee, and she begins to cry sadly.
- "Hey, Caroline, look. I put a lot of thought into this and decided to defer school for now. This werewolf pack I'm helping, they need me. I know it's lame to do this over the phone, but I figure this way's harder for you to kill me. I'm really, really sorry, Care, but this is important. "
- —Tyler to Caroline in a voice message[src]
In For Whom the Bell Tolls, Tyler appears after being a long time away for the funeral of Bonnie, Caroline runs into his arms and they embrace.In Monster's Ball, Caroline and Tyler are having sex in Caroline's room, and Caroline tells Tyler about the ball, she wants him to go to with costumes of Bonnie and Clyde, he agrees to go to the ball with Caroline. They arrive at the dance, he tells her that is the hottest serial killer at that time arrives Stefan and invites to Caroline to dance, tyler agrees and they go to the dance floor. At the ball, they are seen dancing and talking, later, Tyler reveals he didn't came back for Caroline, he came back to say goodbye, and go out to kill Klaus, who took his happiness away from him, Caroline is upset because she don't agree with that, she leaves him alone. At the end, Caroline goes in to Tyler's dorm room, and asks him to stay. She asks if his hate for Klaus, are stronger than his love for her. Caroline tells Tyler if he walks out of the door, it's over, permanently. Tyler is seen in a dilemma for a few seconds, and is seen crying, and walks out of the door, ending their relationship permanently and leaves Caroline, crying sadly.
- Start Up: The Birthday (3x01)
- On Hold: The Ties That Bind (3x12)
- Reason: After Tyler accidentally bites Caroline, he decide to leave the town to break his bond with Klaus, so that he can't hurt Caroline anymore, so until that they are separated. It confirmed by Caroline in Dangerous Liaisons, when she said to Klaus that because of him and his sire bond, that Tyler left town and they break up.
- Back on: Heart of Darkness (3x19)
- On Hold: Down the Rabbit Hole (4x14)
- Reason: Tyler left Mystic Falls to escape Klaus.
- Back On: Graduation (4x23)
- Reason: Klaus allows Tyler to come back to Mystic Falls, giving him his freedom back.
- Ended: Monster's Ball (5x05)
- Reason: Tyler still desires vengeance for Carol's murder at Klaus' hands and breaks up with Caroline so she can have her college experience. He heads to New Orleans.